Shots - Health Blog
Wed September 12, 2012
Portland, Ore., Becomes Latest Fluoride Battleground
Originally published on Wed September 12, 2012 5:58 pm
Over jeers and cheers from the audience, commissioners on the Portland, Ore., City Council voted Wednesday to add fluoride to the city's drinking water starting in 2014.
Portland is the largest American city that doesn't add fluoride to its drinking water. But some groups have raised questions about the possible risks from fluoridation and oppose its use.
Those concerns come despite the long and authoritative list of organizations that endorse fluoridation to prevent tooth decay: the American Medical Association, the American Dental Association, the National Institutes of Health and the American Cancer Society.
The practice has roots in research conducted in the first half of the 20th century, when researchers learned that high levels of naturally occurring fluoride in towns like Colorado Springs were causing children's teeth to grow in brown and mottled. They also noticed that these kids' teeth were surprisingly resistant to decay.
So in 1945, Grand Rapids, Mich., agreed to an experiment to add a small amount of fluoride to its water. An 11-year study by the U.S. surgeon general found that the rate of cavities among children there dropped 60 percent.
Kim Kaminski is among those who remain unconvinced. Kaminski is with Clean Water Portland, which is battling the introduction of fluoride in Portland's water. She cited studies to support her cause. Perhaps the most worrisome was a 2006 Harvard study. A key finding:
"For males less than 20 years old, fluoride levels in drinking water during growth is associated with an increased risk of osteosarcoma."
Osteosarcoma is a bone cancer.
Kaminski said that finding was scary. "This was peer-reviewed and published. It was a very solid study," she said. "And at the time, being a mom it was very concerning to me."
Dr. Catherine Hayes of Health Resources in Action was an adviser to the 2006 study, and she co-authored a follow-up study. In the second study, she said, the researchers looked at samples of bone from people who had the cancer — instead of just gathering information about previous cases of the disease, as the first study had done. The second study showed there's no link between osteosarcoma and fluoride, she said.
"There was no difference in the amount of fluoride in the bone," Hayes said. "That's really significant, because now we're not estimating fluoride intake, we're really measuring it."
But fluoride opponents like Kaminiski aren't buying it. They say the study's co-author, Chester Douglass, received payments from the toothpaste company Colgate-Palmolive.
Hayes says the allegations against Douglass don't hold water. "He was thoroughly investigated by Harvard University — a very extensive investigation — and found completely innocent of any wrongdoing," she said.
The latest study to raise hackles also comes out of Harvard. It went through information from 27 previous studies and concluded that there is "the possibility of an adverse effect of high fluoride exposure on children's neurodevelopment."
The study said more research was needed. But Dr. Myron Allukian of the Harvard School of Dental Medicine says the analysis was flawed.
For starters, he says, there were problems with the Chinese studies included in the meta-analysis. And the effect on IQ was small — accounting for only about a half-point difference, he said. "A half-point difference in IQ is meaningless. That's like saying, we measured all the people in New York and Chicago, and in New York they were a half-millimeter taller."
Portland Commissioner Randy Leonard is among those who endorsed fluoridation. "The people that suffer the most from not having fluoridated systems are kids — and particularly kids of color — and it has to stop," he said.
Despite today's vote, city commissioners may not have the last say. Anti-fluoride advocates want a ballot measure to put the decision before the people.
This story is part of a reporting partnership that includes NPR, Oregon Public Broadcasting and Kaiser Health News.
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News.
Portland, Oregon, has long prided itself on its pure water, free of fluoride. And there's a strong environmental ethic in Portland as well. So when plans emerged to fluoridate the water, the city lit up. And today, over the jeers and cheers of dozens of residents, commissioners voted unanimously to add fluoride.
We have more on the science behind the issue and the debate in Portland from Kristian Foden-Vencil of Oregon Public Broadcasting.
KRISTIAN FODEN-VENCIL, BYLINE: Last century, scientists in Colorado Springs found high levels of naturally occurring fluoride. They also noticed many local children had mottled or brown teeth, but that their teeth were surprisingly resistant to decay. So in 1945, Grand Rapids, Michigan, agreed to an experiment adding small amounts of fluoride to its water. An 11-year study by the U.S. Surgeon General found the rate of cavities among children there dropped 60 percent. But not everyone's convinced.
KIM KAMINSKI: We know that it affects the thyroid gland. We know that it affects insulin secretion. We know that it affects children's IQ levels.
FODEN-VENCIL: Kim Kaminski is battling the introduction of fluoride in Portland's water. She cites many studies to support her cause. Perhaps the most worrisome hit the news in 2006 out of Harvard.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED BROADCASTS)
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: Could fluoridated water cause cancer?
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: We may have a problem with fluoridation in drinking water.
UNIDENTIFIED MAN #3: New research shows...
FODEN-VENCIL: The study found that for boys under 20, fluoride levels in drinking water were associated with an increased risk of osteosarcoma, a bone cancer. Kim Kaminski says that's scary.
KAMINSKI: This was peer reviewed and published, and it's a very solid study. And at the time, being a mom, it was very concerning to me.
FODEN-VENCIL: An adviser to that study was Dr. Catherine Hayes of Health Resources in Action. She was also the co-author of the follow-up study. She says instead of gathering information about previous cases of osteosarcoma, as was done in the first study, they looked at actual samples of bone from people who had the cancer. And, she says, as far as she's concerned, there's no link.
DR. CATHERINE HAYES: In that study, the bone was carefully examined amongst individuals who had the osteosarcoma and those that did not, and there was no difference in the amount of fluoride in the bone. And that's really significant, because now we're not estimating fluoride intake, we're really measuring it.
FODEN-VENCIL: Still, anti-fluoride activists like Kim Kaminski remain unconvinced. They say the co-author, Chester Douglass, received payments from a toothpaste company. Hayes dismisses that concern.
HAYES: He was thoroughly investigated by Harvard University and found completely innocent of any wrongdoing.
FODEN-VENCIL: Portland City Commissioner Randy Leonard has looked at many studies, including the one out of Harvard, and says he's going to go along with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the many other public health agencies that endorse fluoridation.
RANDY LEONARD: It is time for Portland to join every other large city in the United States. And the people that suffer the most from not having fluoridated systems are kids and particularly kids of color, and it has to stop.
FODEN-VENCIL: Still, city commissioners won't have the last say here. Anti-fluoride advocates already have a ballot measure to put to the people. For NPR News, I'm Kristian Foden-Vencil in Portland.
BLOCK: That story is part of a partnership with NPR, Oregon Public Broadcasting and Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.