'We're Fighting For Our Lives': Patients Protest Sky-High Insulin Prices

Dec 10, 2018
Originally published on December 10, 2018 2:19 pm

Angela Lautner knew her thirst was unusual, even for someone directing airplanes, outside in the Memphis summer heat.

"We had coolers of Gatorade and water for people to always have access to," Lautner remembers of her job as a ground services agent. "But the amount of thirst that I felt was just incredible."

She had no appetite and she lost an unusual amount of weight. Then after a trip to the emergency room, Lautner, who was 22, was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes. The diagnosis was life changing.

To start, it meant that for the rest of her life she would require insulin injections every day to keep her alive. Unlike Type 2 diabetes, which can sometimes be controlled by diet, people with Type 1 diabetes need daily insulin injections to regulate their blood sugar.

Lautner's diagnosis also meant she was no longer allowed to become a commercial airline pilot in the U.S. — a lifelong dream that she was training for in flight school at the time.

"I cried harder over losing my dream to fly than I did at the diagnosis of Type 1 diabetes," Lautner says.

But after 18 years living with diabetes, Lautner now says the hardest thing about the diagnosis is accessing insulin — the expensive drug she needs to keep her alive. She's had to borrow money from her parents to pay for insurance; she's spent hours on the phone with drug companies; she's switched brands of insulin to save costs; and she even moved to a new state, Kentucky, with a more generous Medicaid plan.

Last year, Lautner noticed other people with Type 1 diabetes tweeting similar stories under the hashtag #Insulin4All. She read the stories of Shane Patrick Boyle and Alec Raeshawn Smith, two men who died because they could not afford their insulin. It was an epiphany.

"I thought, 'My goodness, there's more people than me. I'm not the only one out here,' " she says.

Since then, Lautner has joined a group of consumer activists, people who need insulin to live and are angry about the sky-high prices. They are putting pressure on the three main companies that make insulin: Sanofi of France, Novo Nordisk of Denmark, and Eli Lilly and Co. in the U.S.

Taking on the drugmakers

The cost of insulin nearly tripled between 2002 and 2013 and has doubled again since then. The list price is over $300 for a single vial of medicine, and most people with Type 1 diabetes need multiple vials every month to live. That cost is typically lower with insurance or with discount programs. Still, for some people the price is unmanageable.

There's been some action by lawmakers on the issue. In October Minnesota's attorney general sued insulin manufacturers alleging price gouging, and a bipartisan caucus in the U.S. Congress issued a report in November urging action to bring insulin prices down.

But prices are still going up, so consumer activists like Lautner are taking things into their own hands.

Nonprofit group T1International, which advocates for Type 1 diabetes around the world, with a particular focus on insulin prices, has started holding rallies outside the Indianapolis headquarters of pharmaceutical giant Eli Lilly and Co. (Eli Lilly and Novo Nordisk have provided financial support to NPR.)

Lautner joined more than 70 people who came together to demonstrate there in September. They were asking for three things: transparency about how much it costs to make a vial of insulin and how much profit comes from each vial, and a commitment from the company to lower the list price of insulin.

There were protesters from at least 12 states, mainly Ohio, Illinois, Indiana and Kentucky, but also from as far away as New York. Lautner, who now lives outside Cincinnati, rented a school bus with a dozen others to make the 112-mile trip.

"Insulin is kind of the face of the drug pricing crisis in America," says Elizabeth Pfiester, founder of T1International and who has Type 1 diabetes herself. "We literally die without it," she says. "We're fighting for our lives."

This was the third time the group had protested at Eli Lilly headquarters. Last fall, when the group held its first protest there, Pfiester says, as it was "the first time where people living with Type 1 were able to physically stand and show that people are angry enough to come out."

Eli Lilly declined NPR's request for an interview, but in statement a spokesperson said, "we understand why people are making their voices heard."

Protesting is one arm of their advocacy efforts; the group is also lobbying at the state and national level, and conducting online awareness-raising campaigns under the hashtag #Insulin4All.

Advocacy at the state level

Last spring, the fight got even more personal for Angela Lautner. She got a letter from her insurance company stating they were no longer going to pay for the insulin she was taking. They wanted to switch her to a different brand.

Most people with Type 1 diabetes use two types of insulin: short-acting insulin to counteract the carbohydrates consumed with meals, and long-acting insulin to keep blood sugar stable throughout the day.

Lautner has found that the long-lasting insulin brand Lantus works best with her body; it keeps her blood sugars low, but not so low that she becomes dangerously hypoglycemic, risking death. But her insurer was dropping its coverage of Lantus in favor of a different long-lasting insulin, Basaglar.

"The problem that I immediately saw was that [Basaglar] had not worked for my body," Lautner says. "So I go into my doctor's office with this letter and I'm like, 'What am I going to do?' "

Lautner's doctor connected her to Sanofi's drug discount program, where she was able to get a month's supply of Lantus for a couple of hundred dollars. So she decided to pay for the insulin herself.

"I'm fortunate enough to have an emergency fund," Lautner says.

But she knows others aren't so lucky.

This year, Lautner organized her own group of diabetes activists in Kentucky, Ohio and Indiana, called KOI Insulin4All. They've met with legislators in all three states about establishing emergency insulin prescription refills and about making the cost of insulin more transparent.

There are similar groups starting up in Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Minnesota and Illinois. In November, activists protested outside the Cambridge, Mass., office of Sanofi. All of them are pushing for the same thing — to make the voices of people with diabetes heard.


Bram Sable-Smith (@besables) is a health reporter based in Madison, Wis.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

Insulin is getting more and more expensive, and that's costing lives. Some people with Type 1 diabetes have died because they couldn't afford the insulin they needed to live. Diabetes activists like Angela Lautner of Elsmere, Ky., say news reports of those deaths have called attention to the crisis.

ANGELA LAUTNER: But what really needs to be told is what Americans are doing to help stop this.

MARTIN: Today we're going to hear the story of a group fighting to bring insulin prices down. Bram Sable-Smith reports.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST)

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER #1: (Chanting) Medicine for people.

BRAM SABLE-SMITH, BYLINE: Angela Lautner was one of more than 70 people demonstrating outside the Indianapolis headquarters of pharmaceutical giant Eli Lilly and Company in September.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST)

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER #1: (Chanting) Medicine for people.

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTERS #1: (Chanting) Not for profit.

SABLE-SMITH: There were protesters from at least 12 states, mainly Ohio, Illinois, Indiana and Kentucky, but also from as far away as New York. It was organized by the nonprofit T1International. The group advocates for people with Type 1 diabetes around the world. Type 1 diabetes requires daily treatment with insulin, and T1International founder Elizabeth Pfiester says the price of that insulin has taken center stage.

ELIZABETH PFIESTER: Insulin is kind of the face of the drug pricing crisis in America because we literally die without it. We're fighting for our lives.

SABLE-SMITH: The price of insulin is skyrocketing. The cost of a single vial has more than doubled since 2012 alone. And despite a series of recent deaths of people who were unable to afford the insulin they needed, there's been little substantive action by lawmakers to bring those prices down, so consumers are taking matters into their own hands. Pfiester and T1International decided to put pressure directly on the three companies that make insulin - Sanofi of France, Novo Nordisk of Denmark and Eli Lilly and Company in Indianapolis. Eli Lilly is a sponsor of NPR. Most of that advocacy happens online. But last year, the group held their first demonstration at the Eli Lilly headquarters.

PFIESTER: It was kind of the first time where people living with Type 1 were able to physically stand and show that people are angry enough to come out.

SABLE-SMITH: They held a second demonstration in May and a third one this September.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST)

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER #2: What do we want?

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTERS #2: Insulin for all.

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER #2: When do we want it?

UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTERS #2: Now.

SABLE-SMITH: They're asking for three things - transparency about how much it costs to make a vial of insulin, how much profits come from each vial and to lower the list price. Eli Lilly declined NPR's request for an interview, but in a statement, a spokesman said, quote, "we understand why people are making their voices heard," end quote. Meanwhile, the number of protesters has swelled with people like Angela Lautner. For 18 years, Lautner thought she was alone in her struggles. She was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes in 2000 when she was in flight school, chasing her dream of becoming a commercial airline pilot. The diagnosis meant she was not allowed to become one.

LAUTNER: I cried harder over losing my dream to fly than I did at the diagnosis of Type 1 diabetes.

SABLE-SMITH: Over time, though, that's changed as she jumped through hurdle after hurdle to get the insulin she needs to live, spending hours on the phone with insurance companies, switching insulin to save costs, even moving to a new state. Then last year, she noticed other people with Type 1 diabetes tweeting similar stories under the hashtag #insulinforall.

LAUTNER: And I thought, my goodness, there's more people than me. I'm not the only one out here.

SABLE-SMITH: And she decided to get involved. After the first rally at Eli Lilly last year, Lautner organized her own group of diabetes activists in Kentucky, Ohio and Indiana.

LAUTNER: We had people show up. And it wasn't to talk about it. It was to organize.

SABLE-SMITH: And organize they have. They've met with legislators in all three states about establishing emergency insulin prescription refills and about making the cost of insulin more transparent. And there are similar groups starting up in Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Illinois all pushing for the same thing - to make the voices of people with diabetes heard. For NPR News, I'm Bram Sable-Smith in Indianapolis. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.