Sometimes rare diseases can let scientists pioneer bold new ideas. That has been the case with a condition that strikes fewer than 100 babies a year in the United States. These infants are born without a functioning immune system.
The disease is called severe combined immunodeficiency, or SCID. "It was made famous in the mid '70s when the 'Bubble Boy' was described in a documentary, and I think it captured the imagination of a lot of people," says Matthew Porteus, a pediatrician at Stanford University.
David Vetter was the boy who spent most of his short life inside a plastic bubble to protect him from infection. He died at age 12 in 1984.
All babies born in the United States are now screened for this condition, and the best treatment today — a bone marrow transplant — succeeds more than 90 percent of the time. The disease remains a source of great interest to researchers.
"This is one of those diseases in which there's probably more doctors and scientists studying the disease than patients who have the disease," Porteus says.
In the 1990s, European scientists actually cured SCID in some patients, using a technique called gene therapy. This process involves removing defective blood cells from a patient, inserting a new gene with the help of a virus and then putting the cells back into the body. Those cells then build up the patient's immune system.
At first, this treatment in the 1990s and early 2000s looked really promising.
"Of the 20 patients, they all had immune recovery," says Donald Kohn, an immunologist at UCLA's Broad Center of Regenerative Medicine and Stem Cell Research. "But, over time, five of them went on to develop a leukemia."
He says 18 of those original patients are still alive today, but the leukemias put an understandable pall on the whole field of gene therapy.
Scientists went to work to figure out how to inject new genes into cells without triggering leukemia, a cancer of blood cells. And they think they've succeeded.
Over time, there has been gradual improvement in gene therapy. The latest advance, reported in the New England Journal of Medicine on Wednesday, details a study of eight infants who have a type of SCID called SCID-X1.
The gene to correct the problem was inserted into a modified version of HIV, the virus that causes AIDS. That engineered virus can't cause AIDS, and it has been further tweaked to reduce the risk that it could trigger leukemia.
Gene therapy has been used successfully over the past decade. Scientists at St. Jude Children's Research Hospital in Memphis, Tenn., modified the procedure for SCID by giving the infants a short course of chemotherapy before introducing the new gene. This helped the new cells take up permanent residence. The babies developed apparently healthy immune systems, according to the new study.
"I am thrilled to see these outstanding results," says Ewelina Mamcarz, a transplant physician and first author on the new paper.
"To be able to see these babies in my clinic now as toddlers is very rewarding," she says. "They live normal lives. They aren't any different from my daughters." Two more infants have been treated since the paper was prepared for publication, the team says.
Standard treatment for SCID is a bone marrow transplant. But that procedure often restores only part of a child's immune system. As a result, patients require monthly infusions of antibodies called immunoglobulins. Jennifer Puck, a pediatrician at UC San Francisco and a collaborator in the latest study, says infants who got the gene therapy don't need that medication.
These children are "growing normally, they're getting colds like everyone else and they're getting over infections — so I would say that is a cure," Puck says.
Of course, she adds, they'll be watched carefully for signs of leukemia and to see if the effect of the therapy is wearing off.
In her view, the key to treatment is finding these children early — through newborn screening — before they start to get life-threatening infections. Screening for SCID is now done throughout the U.S., though its introduction was gradual and state by state.
Before screening was instituted, these children used to show up in the hospital with life-threatening infections, "and now we're seeing happy, bouncy little newborns who just look perfectly normal and they're never sick," Puck says. "Sometimes their families don't understand just how profoundly affected their immune system is."
St. Jude hopes to commercialize its treatment. It has an exclusive licensing agreement with Mustang Bio to develop a product. A similar treatment, called Strimvelis, has already been approved by Europe's equivalent of the Food and Drug Administration. It targets a different mutation that causes SCID, but the technique is very much the same, including the brief dose of chemotherapy.
This latest advance is not only encouraging news for these rare patients. SCID is a test case for all those scientists working to develop better gene therapy techniques.
For example, instead of inserting a healthy gene into blood cells, Porteus, the Stanford pediatrician, has used a precision gene-editing technique called CRISPR to correct the genetic error in blood cells drawn from SCID patients. It works in the laboratory, "and this really sets the stage then for a clinical trial, hopefully in the next 12 to 18 months," he says.
All this makes the leukemia setback from the 1990s feel like a fading memory. Kohn at UCLA says that for more than a decade, it seemed that the field of gene therapy was a dead end.
Clearly it has made a comeback and has been used to treat other rare diseases, including adrenoleukodystrophy, a neurological condition better known as Lorenzo's Oil disease, after a 1992 movie that highlighted a boy with the condition and his parents' hunt for a cure.
Now, with continual advances in treating SCID, "it's just nice to see another success for gene therapy," Kohn says.
You can contact NPR science correspondent Richard Harris at firstname.lastname@example.org.
AILSA CHANG, HOST:
Sometimes rare diseases allow for scientists to pioneer bold new ideas. That's been the case with a condition that affects fewer than a hundred babies a year in the U.S. Those babies are born without a functioning immune system, and the quest to cure them has led to advances in a technique called gene therapy. NPR's Richard Harris reports.
RICHARD HARRIS, BYLINE: The disease is called severe combined immunodeficiency, or SCID. Matt Porteus, a Stanford pediatrician, says you might be familiar with it.
MATT PORTEUS: It was made famous, I guess, in the mid-'70s when the bubble boy was described in a documentary. And I think he capture the imagination of a lot of people.
HARRIS: David Vetter spent most of his short life in a plastic bubble to protect him from infection. He died at the age of 12. Things have come a long way since then. All babies born in the United States are now screened for this condition, and standard treatment - a bone marrow transplant - succeeds more than 90 percent of the time when it's done promptly. Yet SCID remains a source of great interest to researchers.
PORTEUS: This is one of those diseases in which there's probably more doctors and scientists studying the disease than patients who have the disease.
HARRIS: In the 1990s, European scientists actually cured it in some patients using gene therapy. This technique involves removing defective blood cells from a patient, inserting a new gene with the help of a virus and then putting the cells back into the body. Those cells then build up the patient's immune systems. Dr. Donald Kohn at UCLA says at first it looked really good.
DONALD KOHN: And initially, I think of the 20 patients, they all had immune recovery. But over time, five of them went on to develop a leukemia.
HARRIS: Scientists scrambled to figure out how to inject new genes into cells without triggering that blood cancer, and they're cautiously optimistic they've succeeded. Since then, there have been gradual improvements in the technique. The latest advance, involving eight infants, shows that a short dose of chemotherapy helped the new cells take root. The infants ended up with apparently healthy immune systems.
EWELINA MAMCARZ: I am thrilled to see these outstanding results.
HARRIS: Ewelina Mamcarz at St. Jude's Children's Research Hospital in Memphis is first author of a paper reporting these findings in the New England Journal of Medicine.
MAMCARZ: To be able to see these babies in my clinic now as toddlers is really very rewarding. They live normal lives. They're not any different from my daughters.
HARRIS: Today, most children with SCID who get a bone marrow transplant also need ongoing treatment, including lifetime injections of antibodies. Jennifer Puck, a pediatrician at UC-San Francisco and a study collaborator, says infants who got the newest gene therapy don't need that medication.
JENNIFER PUCK: And they're growing normally. They're getting colds like everybody else. And they get over infections, so I would say that that is a cure.
HARRIS: Of course, she adds that they will be watched carefully for signs of leukemia and to see if the effects of the therapy are wearing off. In her mind, the key is finding these children early through newborn screening before they start to get life-threatening infections. That had typically been the case.
PUCK: And now we're seeing happy, bouncy little newborns who just look perfectly normal.
HARRIS: This is not only good news for those rare families. The disease provides a good opportunity for all those scientists to develop even newer gene therapy techniques. For example, instead of inserting a healthy gene, Matt Porteus at Stanford has used a powerful gene-editing technique called CRISPR to correct the genetic error in SCID blood cells. It works with human cells in a dish.
PORTEUS: And this really sets the stage then for testing the approach in a clinical trial hopefully in the next 12 to 18 months.
HARRIS: All this makes the leukemia setback from the 1990s feel like a fading memory. Kohn at UCLA said for more than a decade, it seemed that the field was a dead end but no more.
KOHN: It's just nice to see another success for gene therapy.
HARRIS: Richard Harris, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.