State lawmakers take another step separating teacher reviews from test results

Jan 24, 2019

The New York State Legislature has approved a measure that ends a mandate that teacher evaluations be based on the results of their students’ standardized tests.

It’s another step toward ending a 10-year-old bitter fight between teachers and their unions and politicians, including Gov. Andrew Cuomo, over the implementation of the controversial Common Core learning standards.                    

Buffalo school teacher at the Buffalo Academy for Visual & Performing Arts during a lesson this January in her classroom.
Credit WBFO News photo by Eileen Buckley

Assembly Education Committee Chair Michael Benedetto was a teacher for 35 years before running for office. He said he was routinely evaluated by administrators. They observed him in the classroom and checked over his lesson plans.

He said that worked until in 2010, the evaluations were taken over by what he calls the “political sphere” and teachers’ performance ratings were more closely tied to results of standardized test scores. He said that led to “chaos and uncertainty.”  

“It was a terrible thing, what we have done to the teachers of this state,” Benedetto said. “We decide to say to them, ‘We don’t trust you and you, teachers, are the enemy.’ ”

The bill would permit local school districts to decide whether to use the test results as part of teacher evaluations.

The measure was heralded by the teachers union, New York State United Teachers. Its president, Andy Pallotta, said in a statement that the system was “broken” and needed fixing.

“We look forward to making sure this bill is signed into law immediately, and we will continue to advocate for a meaningful assessment system for New York students that will measure student progress more accurately and address the concerns raised by teachers and parents alike,” Pallotta said.

It now goes to Cuomo, who also recommended the changes in his budget plan. Cuomo initially backed linking teacher evaluations to test scores. 

A spokeswoman would not say whether the governor will sign the Legislature’s bill or wait to approve it as part of the budget.

The controversy led to one-fifth of the state’s students routinely boycotting the tests.